top of page
Search

What Drives a Winning NCAA Softball Offense?

Writer: Brandon Matthews
Brandon Matthews
6 minutes ago
4 min read

Three seasons of college softball data show why OPS stands out, where doubles matter most, and how the sacrifice bunt fits in.


A leadoff hitter works a walk. The next hitter drives a double into right-center, and the runner scores from first. The double gets the dugout on its feet, but the rally started with the walk. Batting average leaves out the walk and gives the double the same credit as a single.


That’s what I wanted to dig into when I looked at NCAA softball from 2024 through 2026. What separates the offenses on teams that win more often? Getting on base and hitting for extra bases both showed up in the numbers. The best single stat I found for capturing both was OPS.


What winning teams did well at the plate

I compared each hitting stat with team winning percentage. In the table below, a higher positive number means teams that did more of it tended to win more often. A number near zero means the stat told us little about which teams won more often.


Is OPS king?

If I get one number to tell me how well a lineup hits, give me OPS. It adds on-base percentage to slugging percentage. On-base percentage gives credit to the hitter who starts the rally with a walk. Slugging gives extra credit to the hitter who drives her home with a double. That’s the inning we opened with, captured in one stat.


In 2026, OPS had the strongest link to winning among the hitting stats I compared in Divisions II and III. It also tracked more closely with winning than batting average or slugging alone in all three divisions. In Division I, on-base percentage edged OPS, .774 to .760. That’s a good reason to pay attention to what hitters do with the pitches they take as well as the ones they swing at. NCAA on-base percentage


OPS gives us the big picture. Look closer at the extra-base hits, and you’ll see where the divisions differed.


Home runs stood out in Division I. Doubles stood out in Division III.


Teams that hit more doubles per game and teams that hit more home runs per game tended to win more often in every division in all three seasons. Home runs had the stronger link in Division I each year. Doubles had the stronger link in Division III each year. Division II shifted. Doubles led in 2024 and 2025, and home runs pulled ahead in 2026.



Here’s how that looked in the 2026 standings. I ranked teams by how often they hit doubles or homers per game, then compared the top quarter with the bottom quarter in each division.



That Division III doubles gap is worth noticing. A hitter who can drive the ball into the gap can score a runner from first or put herself in scoring position with one swing.

Speed showed up in the Division III numbers, too. Stolen bases had a stronger relationship with winning in D3 than in D1 or D2 in all three seasons. Even in D3, getting on base and slugging each had a stronger link to winning than steals did.


So, are you going to bunt your way to a championship?

I wouldn’t build my offense around the sacrifice bunt. Over the three seasons, recorded sacrifice bunts per game had almost no relationship with winning in Division I and a modest positive relationship in Divisions II and III. In every division and every season, doubles and home runs each had a stronger relationship with winning than recorded sacrifices did.


There’s still a time to call one. In the bottom of the last inning of a tie game, moving the winning runner into scoring position can make sense. Who’s at the plate? Who’s on deck? Who’s on base? Those details matter. The NCAA season totals count officially scored sacrifices. They don’t capture every bunt attempt, tell us whether a team should have bunted in a particular spot, or prove that any one tactic wins championships.


What I’d take to the field

  • For hitters, know which pitch you can drive and be ready to swing hard when you get it. A hard line drive into the gap can change an inning. So can taking a close pitch for ball four with a good hitter behind you.

  • For coaches, look at on-base percentage and slugging side by side. If the lineup rarely puts runners on, find out why. If runners get on and keep getting stranded, watch what your hitters do with pitches they can drive. Teach the bunt so your team can execute it when you call for it.


If I’m planning a week of practice, I’ll make time for the bunt. I’ll spend more of that time helping hitters recognize pitches they can drive, take pitches they can’t, and make hard contact when they get their chance. Those are the skills I want throughout the lineup.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page